Independent handicapper reviews and records21+ · Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER
NHL - Matchup Picks

St. Louis Blues vs Pittsburgh Penguins Predictions

St. Louis visits Pittsburgh after an 8-6 win over Anaheim, while the Penguins bring a six-game home winning streak against the Blues. SPF favors Pittsburgh; SportsJaw forecasts a narrow St. Louis win. Both betting leans are Pass, with starting goalies unconfirmed and prices varying across the supplied books.

November 19, 2026 · 6:00 PM CST · PPG Paints Arena

SpreadSTL +1.5PIT -1.5
MoneylineSTL Not availablePIT Not available
TotalOver 6.5Under 6.5
The Verdict

Matchup Assessment

ForecastSt. Louis Blues to Win

St. Louis Blues 4 · Pittsburgh Penguins 3

SportsJaw ConsensusNot Available

No published consensus supplied for this matchup.

Handicapper Picks

Who Has A Pick On This Game?

Showing 10 handicappers, ranked by their last 30-day return (USD) for this sport, highest first. Missing returns appear last. Open a profile to visit the capper’s website for the current selection. Paid sides are not disclosed here. Records, win rates and returns cover this sport over the last 30 days.

HandicapperMarketNHL RecordWin %Return (USD)
Jacob MartinTotal(81 - 42)65.9%+$14,638
Jacob SmithMoney(78 - 41)65.6%+$12,385
Trevor J. BassMoney(49 - 29)62.8%+$6,662
Pete MacSpread(41 - 30)57.8%+$4,980
Scooter LowellMoney(71 - 55)56.4%+$3,688
Vincent KingMoney(36 - 28)56.3%+$3,538
Joel RockmanTotal(63 - 47)57.3%+$636
Harold WindhamMoney(35 - 34)50.7%-$1,536
Peter TrellSpread(29 - 33)46.8%-$1,552
Taylor GoldSpread(42 - 44)48.8%-$3,842

Checked November 19, 2026 08:00 AM CST. Listings can change and do not imply agreement on a side.

Sportsbook comparison

Latest Odds

Latest supplied quotes. Prices can change.

St. Louis Blues vs Pittsburgh Penguins Spread
TeamDraftKingsFanDuelBetMGM
STL+1.5 (-285)+1.5 (-310)-1.5 (+220)
PIT-1.5 (+230)-1.5 (+225)+1.5 (-275)

American odds · DraftKings, FanDuel and BetMGM only · Data supplied through SportsJaw

Scheduled gameNovember 19, 2026 · 6:00 PM CST
VenuePPG Paints Arena

Key Matchup Factors

St. Louis Blues vs Pittsburgh Penguins

HR Prediction Analysis

Breaking down the projected margin, scoring outlook, and key factors shaping this matchup.

Reading The Forecast

The forecasts disagree: SPF narrowly favors Pittsburgh because it has won six straight home meetings with St. Louis, while SportsJaw projects a 4-3 Blues win after their recent offensive surge. Both call for a betting pass. The moneyline is close, with BetMGM listing both teams at -110, so neither forecast establishes an attractive price. The puck line also varies across books: FanDuel lists Pittsburgh -1.5, while BetMGM lists St. Louis -1.5. SportsJaw’s seven-goal projection exceeds its listed 5.5 total, but the supplied book totals are 6 or 6.5. St. Louis scored eight against Anaheim but conceded six, and neither previous-game goalie is confirmed to start. Those uncertainties limit conclusions about either side or total.

Injury Report

From SportsJaw’s published matchup research on November 18, 2026. Availability may have changed since publication.

Covers lists Elmer Soderblom as week-to-week with an upper-body injury, Bryan Rust on injured reserve with a lower-body injury, and Ryan Graves out with a lower-body injury. These are relevant personnel concerns, although the report supplies no numerical estimate of their effect on this matchup.

Before The Game

  • Confirm both starting goalies before assessing the moneyline or total.
  • Recheck the puck line and total, which differ across the supplied books.
  • Verify Pittsburgh’s dated injury statuses before evaluating its lineup.

Sources & Editorial Notes

Prepared for November 19, 2026. The forecast uses SportsJaw’s published assessment. Research and pick listings are publication snapshots; the three-book odds board refreshes separately.

Consensus is a selection-share estimate, not observed betting volume or a probability of winning. Team availability mentioned in research should be rechecked before the start.