Independent handicapper reviews and records21+ · Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER
HandicappingReviews
NHL - Matchup Picks

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Predictions

The Islanders return from a California trip that included two wins, while Columbus arrives on a four-game losing streak with a 1-5-0 road record. New York is the forecast winner, but the starting goalies were unconfirmed in the supplied preview. The -142 moneyline and 5.5 total remain passes.

November 17, 2026 · 6:00 PM CST · UBS Arena

SpreadCBJ Not availableNYI Not available
MoneylineCBJ Not availableNYI Not available
TotalOver Not availableUnder Not available
The Verdict

Matchup Assessment

ForecastNew York Islanders to Win
SportsJaw ConsensusNot Available

No published consensus supplied for this matchup.

Handicapper Picks

Who Has A Pick On This Game?

Showing 3 handicappers, ranked by their last 30-day return (USD) for this sport, highest first. Missing returns appear last. Open a profile to visit the capper’s website for the current selection. Paid sides are not disclosed here. Records, win rates and returns cover this sport over the last 30 days.

HandicapperMarketNHL RecordWin %Return (USD)
Joel RockmanTotal(62 - 47)56.9%+$116
Tyler SamuelsTotal(30 - 37)44.8%-$3,125
Harold WindhamTotal(32 - 37)46.4%-$3,545

Checked November 17, 2026 08:00 AM CST. Listings can change and do not imply agreement on a side.

Sportsbook comparison

Latest Odds

Latest supplied quotes. Prices can change.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Moneyline
TeamDraftKingsFanDuelBetMGM
CBJNot available+116+118
NYINot available-140-145

American odds · DraftKings, FanDuel and BetMGM only · Data supplied through SportsJaw

Scheduled gameNovember 17, 2026 · 6:00 PM CST
VenueUBS Arena

Key Matchup Factors

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders

HR Prediction Analysis

Breaking down the projected margin, scoring outlook, and key factors shaping this matchup.

Reading The Forecast

New York is the forecast winner on the strength of a 9-6-4 record, a four-game point streak and wins over Los Angeles and Anaheim on its California trip. Columbus has lost four straight and is 1-5-0 away, although Kent Johnson's 13 points over his previous 10 games give the visitors a scoring threat. The Islanders moneyline was -142 at FanDuel and -145 at BetMGM. The supplied preview passes at -142 because neither starting goalie was confirmed. That uncertainty also limits any read on the 5.5 total. The puck line asks New York to win by two goals at prices around +170 to +180, a larger claim than the outright forecast supports. There is no supported wager on the moneyline, puck line or total.

Injury Report

No injury report was supplied for this matchup. Check team availability before the game.

Before The Game

  • Confirm both starting goalies and review any pregame changes to the announced lineups.
  • Recheck the Islanders moneyline against the supplied -142 price before assessing its value.
  • Verify the 5.5 total and current prices after the starting goalies are announced.

Sources & Editorial Notes

Prepared for November 17, 2026. The forecast uses Sports Picks Forum’s published assessment. Research and pick listings are publication snapshots; the three-book odds board refreshes separately.

Consensus is a selection-share estimate, not observed betting volume or a probability of winning. Team availability mentioned in research should be rechecked before the start.